New Book Review: "Ethics of Big Data"
New book review for Ethics of Big Data: Balancing Risk and Innovation, by Kord Davis and Doug Patterson, O'Reilly, 2012, reposted here:
A very much needed, extremely well written essay on what the authors call the "forcing function" of Big Data – a push to consider serious ethical issues in light of the usage of Big Data – and how to improve one's organization by utilizing the results of ethical inquiry. In just 64 pages, Davis and Patterson walk the reader through what would have likely been a much more unreachable topic had it been written by another team, and the result is arguably one of the best business texts in the year-2012 marketplace.
After discussing Big Data and Big Data forcing in Chapter 1 ("Big Data, Big Impact"), the authors turn to values, ethical inquiry, and "ethical decision points" in Chapter 2 ("Values and Actions"), followed by a survey of current ethical practices by businesses in Chapter 3 ("Current Practices") and a component-by-component discussion of the the Alignment Methodology Framework introduced earlier in the book in Chapter 4 ("Aligning Values and Actions").
What makes this text so well put together is not just the writing style of the authors, but its organization and inclusion of many examples throughout the discussion that are likely to increase the practicality of the discussion. While Davis and Patterson do formally include a brief case study at the conclusion of Chapter 4, it is the small examples that carry the heavy lifting. And while the Alignment Methodology Framework at a surface level is reminiscent of the familiar Plan-Do-Check-Act cycle, the specifics that the authors provide for each step specifically target organizational values and how to align actions with those values.
Use of the buzzword "innovation" in the subtitle to this effort is actually well placed, unlike the inappropriate use of what can be seen as a buzzword in itself, "Big Data", in some other books in this year's business shelf. As the authors in Chapter 2 comment, "While big data represents both tremendous opportunity (in the form of new products and services) for broad business and social benefit, the opposite side of that coin is that it also represents serious risk. Finding and maintaining a balance between the benefits of innovation and the detriments of risks is, in part, a function of ethical inquiry."
"Developing a capability to find and maintain that balance is partially ethical because of the essential nature of the technology itself…Ethics come into play, in part, when organizations realize that information has value that can be extracted and turned into new products and services. The degree to which ethics play a role in this process is, of course, more complicated that a simple identification of which information is 'ancillary' and which is not. The ethical impact is highly context-dependent. But to ignore that there is an ethical impact is to court an imbalance between the benefits of innovation and the detriments of risk."